Hire a link building specialist or an agency?

11 min read · Published 19 Nov 2026 · By the Crackify team

When link building becomes a priority, the next question is who should do it. An in-house link building specialist knows your business inside out; an agency brings contacts, tools and capacity; a hybrid tries to get both.

This guide explains what a good specialist does, the strengths and limits of each option, interview questions, the tools a specialist needs and how to set realistic expectations.

Key takeaways

  • In-house suits steady, long-term programmes with a clear owner.
  • Agencies suit faster scale, PR reach and specialist skills.
  • Many teams combine one in-house lead with an agency.
  • Quality standards matter more than volume either way.

What a good specialist does

  • Finds and vets relevant sites
  • Writes outreach that gets replies
  • Builds relationships with editors and journalists
  • Plans links around priority pages
  • Reports on links and organic impact
In-house or agency?
Illustration, example data

In-house strengths and limits

An in-house specialist is close to your product and experts, which makes stories and approvals faster. The limits are capacity, journalist networks and tools, which take time and budget to build. One person can only send so many good pitches a week.

Agency strengths and limits

Agencies bring existing relationships, processes and capacity to scale quickly. The trade-off is less day-to-day product knowledge, so a clear brief and fast approvals on your side matter.

Interview questions for a specialist

  1. Show us links you built and explain how you got each one.
  2. How do you decide whether a site is worth a link?
  3. Walk us through an outreach email you would send for us.
  4. How would you measure your success after six months?
  5. What tactics would you refuse to use?

Tools a specialist needs

  • An SEO platform for backlink data and competitor research
  • An outreach or email tool with tracking
  • Access to journalist request platforms or a media database
  • A tracker or CRM for prospects and placements
  • Search Console access for your site

A worked example

An illustrative SaaS company hires its first link building specialist. In the first quarter she reclaims existing mentions, fixes broken pages with backlinks and sets up journalist request monitoring. In the second, she runs broken link outreach with the company’s best guides and briefs an agency for one data campaign. By month six there is a steady flow of relevant links and a clear view of what to scale.

Red flags when hiring

  • Portfolios made only of link counts and domain scores
  • Examples on sites with no real traffic
  • Reliance on buying links rather than earning them
  • No interest in your product or audience
  • Promises of fixed numbers in the first month

The first 90 days

  1. Weeks 1 to 2: audit current links, competitors and priority pages.
  2. Weeks 3 to 6: reclamation, redirects and journalist request monitoring.
  3. Weeks 7 to 10: first outreach campaign with your best content.
  4. Weeks 11 to 13: report results and agree the next quarter’s plan.

A plan like this gives a new hire early wins while building toward the slower, larger results.

Setting expectations

A new specialist needs time to build relationships and learn your product. Expect early wins from reclamation and commentary, with larger results after several months. Agree measures upfront: relevant links to priority pages, not raw link counts. If you want capacity while you hire, an agency can run campaigns alongside your specialist.

Frequently asked questions

What skills should we hire for?

Research, writing, relationship building and basic SEO analysis.

Which tools does a specialist need?

An SEO tool for link data, an outreach tool and a media database or monitoring service.

Can one person do PR and link building?

In a small programme, yes. Larger programmes usually split the roles.

Should a specialist report to SEO or marketing?

Usually SEO, with close links to PR and content teams.

Can we combine a specialist with an agency?

Yes. The specialist can manage the agency and handle in-house relationships.

Send us the reply card.

Tell us about your site and where you want to be covered. We reply with a tailored campaign idea and a list of target publications, free and with no obligation.

  1. 1We read your site and check your current links.
  2. 2Within two working days you get an idea and target outlets.
  3. 3If it fits, we send a proposal with scope and price.

Rather email? hello@crackify.net

Reply cardTakes about a minute
Interested in (optional)

We use your details only to reply. See the privacy policy.